Repair vs Replace Washing Machine: How to Decide

Got a washer that’s making weird noises or leaking? Before you order a brand‑new model, take a quick look at a few key factors. A smart decision can save you a lot of cash and avoid unnecessary hassle.

Check the Cost of Repair

The first number you need is the repair quote. Call a local tech, describe the problem, and ask for a rough estimate. If the quote is under 30% of the price of a comparable new machine, fixing it usually makes sense. Anything higher, especially if the issue involves the motor or drum, often means you’re better off buying new.

Don’t forget labour. Some shops charge a flat visit fee plus parts. Ask if the price includes a warranty on the repair – a good warranty can tilt the balance toward fixing.

Consider Age and Efficiency

Washing machines typically last 10‑12 years. If yours is older than that, you’re probably missing out on energy‑saving technology. Newer models use less water and electricity, which can lower your bills by up to 25%.

Check the serial number (usually on the door frame) to see the manufacture year. If the machine is close to the end of its life, even a cheap repair might just be a short‑term fix.

Another red flag is frequent breakdowns. Two or three repairs in a year suggest the machine is wearing out. In that case, replacement is often the smarter financial move.

Look at the parts that fail most often. The pump, door seal, and heating element are cheap to replace and can extend life. If the problem is a key component like the motor or control board, those parts are pricey and may not last long after replacement.

Ask yourself how you use your washer. Large families or heavy‑load users put more strain on the machine. If you’re constantly running big loads, a newer, higher‑capacity model could be worth the upgrade.

Don’t forget the environmental angle. Repairing reduces waste, but a very old, inefficient machine can use more energy than the carbon saved by fixing it. Many retailers now offer recycling for old appliances, so you can feel good about the switch.

Finally, check for any manufacturer recalls or safety notices. If your model has a known defect, a replacement might be required by law, and you could get a discount or credit.

Bottom line: add up the repair cost, compare it to the price of a new, efficient washer, and factor in age, frequency of past repairs, and your usage pattern. When the numbers line up, you’ll know whether to call a tech or start shopping for a fresh machine.